Free tool
Lease vs buy calculator for fleet vehicles
Buying is cheaper when the loan payments and down payment, minus what the vehicle sells for at the end, cost less than the lease over the same term. Enter both offers and the tool shows the total cost of each and the difference.
Your comparison
Enter the term, the vehicle price and the monthly lease payment to compare.
No taxes or deductions are applied: sales taxes and how lease payments, interest and depreciation are deducted differ by province, state and business. Ask your accountant.
Why compare the whole term
A lease payment is usually lower than a loan payment for the same vehicle, so comparing monthly payments alone favours the lease. The fair comparison is the total paid over the same term. On the buy side, the vehicle is still worth something at the end, so its resale value comes off the cost. On the lease side, upfront amounts, end-of-lease fees and charges for distance over the allowance are added on.
Know the distance before the lease ends
Excess distance charges and resale value both depend on how far each vehicle runs. High Point GPS fleet tracking records every trip and the distance run, with engine hours and maintenance reminders for each vehicle, so you can see which units are heading past their lease allowance and plan service before it costs you. FleetZap keeps the maintenance work orders.
Get a quoteTips for a fair comparison
Use the same term for both sides. A five-year loan against a three-year lease compares two different things.
Base the resale value on prices for the same model, age and distance, not on the price you paid.
Estimate excess distance from what the vehicle really runs in a year, multiplied by the lease term, minus the allowance.
Ask the leasing company for every end-of-lease fee in writing: disposition, wear and tear, and any purchase option.
Lease or buy questions
- How do I compare leasing and buying a vehicle?
- Add up everything you pay over the same term for each option. For buying, that is the down payment plus every loan payment, minus the resale value at the end. For leasing, it is the upfront amount, every lease payment, end-of-lease fees and excess distance charges. The option with the lower total costs less over that term.
- Why does the calculator subtract the resale value?
- When you buy, you still own the vehicle at the end of the term and can sell it or trade it in. That value is money back, so it lowers the real cost of buying. A lease returns the vehicle to the leasing company, so nothing comes back. Leaving resale out would make buying look more expensive than it is.
- Which lease costs are easy to miss?
- The monthly payment is only part of a lease. Many leases also ask for an amount upfront, charge a fee when the vehicle is returned, bill for wear beyond normal use, and charge for every kilometre or mile over the allowance. Fleet vehicles that run long distances can pass the allowance quickly, so excess distance charges deserve a careful estimate.
- Does the calculator include taxes and deductions?
- No. Sales taxes, and how lease payments, interest and depreciation can be deducted, differ between Canada and the United States and between provinces and states, and they depend on your business. The calculator compares the amounts you enter only. Ask your accountant how taxes and deductions change the result for your fleet before you decide.
- Should a fleet lease or buy its vehicles?
- It depends on your numbers. Buying tends to suit vehicles you keep for a long time or drive far, since there is no distance allowance and the resale value comes back to you. Leasing can suit vehicles you replace often or want to keep off a loan. Run both offers through the calculator with your own figures to compare them.